About this episode
Nick Wright recaps every game of Wild Card Weekend from the NFL Playoffs, starting with Aaron Rodgers and the Pittsburgh Steelers' 30-6 blow out loss to CJ Stroud's Houston Texans. Is this the end of Aaron Rodgers? Will Mike Tomlin be back in Pittsburgh? Afterwards, Nick reacts to Jalen Hurts, Nick Sirianni, and the Philadelphia Eagles being eliminated... will Philly consider moving on from their head coach? Then, Nick breaks down how Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears were able to pull off their historic comeback against the Packers, and what is next for Jordan Love and Green Bay. After, Nick debates why the Buffalo Bills should be the Super Bowl favorites after Josh Allen's heroic performance in Jacksonville. Later, Nick and Damonza answer your questions. #Volume See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Episode summary
Welcome to What's Right, episode 414, fresh off a wild card slate that felt all‑time, and yes, I’m still enjoying the end of the Eagles’ title run; eight of the nine best teams are still alive, so divisional weekend should be a blast.
Wild card wrapped with Texans over the Steelers, and Aaron Rodgers said he won’t rush a decision; at forty‑two, is this the end?
I went in thinking he’d be back, but the broadcast tone and postgame treatment screamed farewell, and I could see him retiring now and flirting with a late‑season return if a contender loses a QB. His legacy is a paradox: peerless talent, prickly leadership, visible blame‑pointing, freezing out guys after mistakes, and playoff inconsistency that leaves him 11‑11 with one trip, more Will Chamberlain than serial ring‑collector.
There are rumors the Steelers might move on from Tomlin; should they?
I wouldn’t, but I get the fatigue: seven straight playoff losses, several no‑shows, and a decade without a win is a lot to stomach, even if last night was more about offensive futility than a blowout. I’d fear the carousel, and it hasn’t only been an offensive problem in these exits.
Credit the Texans’ defense for surviving an ugly game while the offense sputtered, but they’ll need that same ferocity next week. The Niko Collins sequence looked like an avoidable concussion spiral to me, and that’s hard to watch.
After a season of iffy form, Philly’s out; you’ve been calling it—how do you see it now?
This was the Eagles all year: a stop‑start offense, no dominant run game, and long, cold stretches you can’t just flip in January; Jalen had a bad day, but he’s earned more grace than Sirianni, who never solved the offense, stuck with the wrong coordinator plan, and never got the A.J. Brown situation settled. His seat is hot next season, and their cap approach with heavy void years makes big moves like trading A.J. complex and compresses their window before a reset.
On the Niners, the injuries are relentless—there’s even a wild power‑plant theory floating around—and losing stars again makes the path thin. Shanahan’s coaching has been masterful and Purdy was gutsy, but it feels like they’re holding it together with tape.
Your boy Caleb pulled off that comeback on Green Bay; is that the vision you had when you were high on him last year?
That fourth‑and‑eight laser sliding left with bodies closing was a ‘only two or three humans alive can do this’ throw, and the Bears keep pulling off double‑digit comebacks in the final minutes. Green Bay’s collapse was stunning, and once their top defensive difference‑maker went down, their ceiling fell in.
You said the Bills‑Jags winner would go to the Super Bowl; still feel that way after that finish?
Josh Allen’s on a playoff heater—huge throw to set up the winner, playing through pain, and stacking legend games even with roster holes—while Trevor forced the late pick when a field goal was in play. Buffalo should’ve milked the clock on the one, but they survived, and with Josh’s altitude chops, Denver won’t scare them.
Quick media sidebar: the Jags reporter telling the coach to keep his head up caused outrage; you buy it?
People showed their whole backside getting mad at a kind veteran trying to lift someone in a raw moment; a little humanity won’t break journalism. I’d love every presser to feature a ‘Homer’ and a ‘Hater’ chair—one boost, one burn—and make the coach handle both.
Quick hits: Drake May settled in for New England while Herbert’s postseason slump deepened, with missed shots and jittery reads adding to a rough playoff résumé; the Pats can hang with Houston. The Rams escaped the Panthers in an ugly one, Puka saved the day with a brilliant breakup, and my board right now says Rams over Bills for the whole thing.
Great weekend, great show—send your questions and we’ll hit more on Thursday; tell your mom hi out in L.A., and I’ll see you with Colin in about an hour.