The Herd with Colin Cowherd
--% time saved
PodcastThe Herd with Colin Cowherd
Publisher/creatoriHeartPodcasts and The Volume
Published
Shortcast updated
About this episode
On this episode of 3 & Out , John Middlekauff dives into the Steelers getting scooped by the Cowboys in the Lemon trade and what it says about how quickly deals come together in the NFL. Did Pittsburgh miss an opportunity, or did Dallas simply outmaneuver them at the right time? John also takes a broader look at this year’s draft classes—who stood out, which teams helped themselves the most, and where some organizations may have come up short. Plus, is the pressure starting to mount on Giants GM Joe Schoen? John discusses where things stand in New York and whether his seat is getting hot. He also reacts to the news of Brendan Sorsby entering rehab for gambling, addressing the seriousness of the situation and what it could mean for his future. To wrap things up, it’s the Middlekauff Mailbag , answering your questions and covering a wide range of NFL topics. Follow John on Twitter , and Instagram for the latest. All lines provided by Hard Rock Bet #Volume See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Listen to the original episode
Loading episode data...
Episode summary
What is up, my people—Three and Out back in your ears. We’ve got Eagles‑Cowboys‑Steelers drama, draft grades sanity checks, a QB hitting gambling rehab, Dad Diaries, and a fat mailbag, so let’s talk ball.
Q: You said the Steelers got outfoxed by Howie—what actually happened? A: The Cowboys knew Pittsburgh’s target because loose chatter got back to Dallas, and Jerry green‑lit a deal with Philly; that’s business, not sentiment, and it exposed how behind the Steelers are operationally.
Q: What’s the draft‑season lesson here? A: Keep your board airtight, because once others know your pick, your division rival can become your trade partner’s best friend.
Q: How should we treat draft grades? A: Fun to read, but teams with early ammo get praised by default—Browns and Jets looked strong, while clubs picking late or missing round one were graded on a harder curve.
Q: Why did this draft feel odd? A: Shallow class, tons of older prospects thanks to NIL and transfers, and a tight end run driven by supply more than star power.
Q: Do late picks really matter? A: Absolutely—day‑three and undrafted guys make rosters every year, while plenty of first‑rounders fail fifth‑year options.
Q: Any front‑office smoke? A: The Giants vibe says roster reset, bigger bodies, and some real questions about Joe Schoen’s runway under a head coach who’s steering the identity.
Q: About the next QB class and Brennan Soresby’s news? A: Gambling rehab throws a wrench into projections, leagues are ultra‑sensitive on this stuff, and we should cool it with 1983‑level comps.
Q: Change‑of‑scenery trade you noticed? A: Tyree Wilson to the Saints is a cheap swing, but it’s a reminder that traits without pass‑rush instincts usually don’t age well.
Q: Dad Diaries check‑in? A: House is quiet while the crew’s away, and yeah I miss the little guy; those brutal first months give way to you getting sappy fast.
Q: Who gets held accountable for bad drafts? A: Winning buys cover—Trey Lance was an all‑timer miss, but the Niners kept stacking wins, so the heat never landed the same.
Q: Packers brain trust or Niners? A: I’d take Kyle over LaFleur, Gute over Lynch, and as a package I lean Niners because elite coaching is the tiebreaker.
Q: Early read on Dan Morgan in Carolina? A: Strong start and a tougher roster, but the ceiling still rides on a small quarterback holding up and producing.
Q: Are the Cardinals playing a long game at QB? A: Roll with Carson Beck, take your lumps in a brutal division, then you’re positioned to strike for next year’s guy.
Q: Why do the Niners’ boards look so different? A: Coaches drive the bus; that’s why you see aggressive veteran trades and conviction picks like Stribling at thirty‑three and the Indiana back later.
Q: Did the Giants reach on Arvel Reese? A: They’ll use him off the ball, the upside’s massive, and I get passing on the safer safety for a potential game‑wrecker.
Q: Chiefs taking Garrett Nussmeier—what’s the read? A: If healthy, he’s a steady, low‑athlete, high‑processing backup profile and good value late.
Q: Big Ten versus SEC right now? A: SEC is still deeper top to bottom, but the Big Ten’s elite has closed the gap, and NIL is scrambling recruiting maps.
Q: Why so many tight ends on day two? A: Depth plus a positional run; this wasn’t a parade of Hall of Famers so much as the board pushing teams there.
Q: Chiefs jumped the Saints again—how? A: Great information discipline and cluster planning; leaks and agent chatter move boards, and Kansas City pounced on Mansour Delane.
Q: What’s draft day like for a scout? A: Long waits, constant board restacks, be ready when your number gets called.
Q: Did the Rams bet big on Ty Simpson? A: I’d have taken Rubin Bain and built a nightmare front, because asking a rookie to carry a pass‑heavy plan is a different kind of gamble.
That’s the show—appreciate you riding with me, and we’ll talk ball again tomorrow.
Ready to save time?
Download Shortcast and get started today