Shortcast

AI Podcast Player

Short podcasts with real voices

The Herd with Colin Cowherd
Best of The Herd
--% time saved
Loading episode data...
Episode Summary

Draft day, I’m amped. This class feels lighter at the top, with only a few truly clean blue chips — Fernando Mendoza, Jeremiah Love, and Caleb Downs — while many of the big-money positions have nitpicks, so it’s not a jump-up draft to me.

My top‑half mock in short: Raiders lock in Mendoza, the Jets grab instant-pressure David Bailey, Arizona bets on Arvelle Reese’s ceiling, Tennessee gives Cam Ward a star in Jeremiah Love, and Jim Harbaugh lands the sure-thing safety in Caleb Downs. Cleveland and Washington fortify tackle, the Saints add Carnell Tate, Kansas City nabs Rubin Bane, the Giants fix the interior with Benga Yowane, Miami is thrilled with Mansoor Delane, Dallas scoops Sonny Styles if he slips, the Rams invest in Monroe Freeling, Baltimore adds Makai Lemon, and Tampa Bay takes a small‑school ballhawk in Emanuel McNeil‑Warren.

I like your Rams tackle idea, but I doubt they’d pass on Makai Lemon given the Puka situation and uncertainty around Davante; and Jeremiah Love that high is spicy.

Saleh’s got to support his young quarterback now, not later, and several teams will walk away feeling like they stole a guy; the Dolphins landing the top corner in the teens is exactly that.

On Mendoza, don’t compare him to long-time pros; stack him against recent first‑rounders. I’d only lock in Caleb Williams and Drake May ahead of him, maybe consider Jaden Daniels, C.J. Stroud, and Trevor Lawrence, and I’m out on the Matt Ryan comp — the tape shows real juice as a runner and toughness you can build around.

Trades will scramble boards, and the Jets need a ready‑now edge like Bailey or they’re drafting for the next regime. As for Downs, he’s rare: a freshman who led Alabama in tackles, then mastered three systems in three years, with Ed Reed‑style instincts and disguise — he can align anywhere and still play the right role post‑snap.

Every draft has a slider, and positional value could push Sonny Styles down because teams prioritize quarterbacks, tackles, edge, and premium weapons; great player, but rooms often choose protection over off‑ball linebacker.

I still love Styles; the safety background gives me Brian Urlacher and Fred Warner vibes — captain traits, range, and coverage fluidity. Also, brace for a surprise like the Giants eyeing Jordan Tyson, and expect someone to trade up for a favorite.

Back to Mendoza — he’s not a statue. The red‑zone and fourth‑down runs, the willingness to take a hit and keep gains alive, it’s more like a less‑athletic Andrew Luck than a pocket‑only profile.

He was nails in big road moments and has the experience profile that correlates with Super Bowl winners: lots of starts and real volume. The Raiders have a better runway than most top‑pick teams, with improved protection, Ashton Jeanty, Brock Bowers, and ownership that believes in him.

They’ve got Colton Miller, added real speed outside, and I like the GM. This is the first time in a long while I’m genuinely in on the Raiders’ direction.

One more to watch: Ty Simpson sneaking into round one, maybe via an Arizona trade back in; the Rams also love Makai Lemon. And selecting a running back that high only stings the cap if you’re not offsetting it with a cheap quarterback window.

If a guy is special, you take him. Contenders may consolidate picks for quality over quantity — think the Weddle move years ago — so look for smart, surgical trade‑ups from rosters that only need a piece or two. Draft night’s here; let’s see who actually cashes in.

Download on the App Store
QR Code - Scan to download

Ready to save time?

Download Shortcast and get started today

Download on the App Store
QR Code - Scan to download