About this episode
Former NFL scout John Middlekauff is reacting LIVE immediately following the Week 15 Monday Night Football matchup between Tua Tagovailoa and the Miami Dolphins vs. Aaron Rodgers and Pittsburgh Steelers. John kicks off talking about Miami Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa's inability to play in cold weather games & why the Dolphins may need to get rid of Tua. John then talks about the Pittsburgh Steelers playoff picture after Dolphins win gives them a one game lead on the Baltimore Ravens leading the AFC North with 3 games to go. John talks about how 49ers will probably not go to the Super Bowl but why it could be Kyle Shanahan's best coaching year of his career with the absurd amount of injuries to his star players. John also talks about how the Packers look moving forward without star edge rusher Micah Parsons ahead of a high stakes NFC North road battle against the NFC first place Chicago Bears this upcoming Saturday night, and what this could mean for head coach Matt LaFleur's future with the team. Lastly, John dives into his DMs and discusses the trend of older quarterbacks starting in the NFL & why teams pull the trigger to start guys like Joe Flacco & Philip Rivers than players they don't trust like Anthony Richardson. 05:01 - Dolphins-Steelers 24:09 - 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan 26:15 - Green Bay Packers 31:44 - Why are there so many old QBs starting in the NFL? 45:00- Mailbag Follow John on Twitter , Instagram and YouTube for the latest. All lines provided by Hard Rock Bet Use promo code “3ANDOUT20” on https://nicokick.com/zone for 20% off at checkout! Check out Gametime - the fastest growing ticketing app in the US, and the official ticketing app of 3 & Out and GoLow - for tickets to all of your favorite NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA teams. Concert and comedy show tickets, too. Go to Gametime now to create an account, download the app and use code JOHN for $20 off your first purchase. #Volume See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Episode summary
How we doing—probably better than Tua and the Dolphins after getting handled in that deep-freeze by Rodgers and the Steelers. I’m sitting in Scottsdale in short sleeves while they’re out there in single digits, and I still respect the hell out of Rodgers slinging it with a busted hand.
Quick housekeeping: if you’re on Colin’s feed, hit subscribe on the 3 and Out feed, jump on the YouTube, and we’ll be live Thursday night after Rams‑Seahawks. Big one.
Cold-weather football exposes arm talent. Velocity matters when the air hurts and the ball’s a rock, which is why Brady, Ben, and Flacco thrived, and why dome or warm‑weather guys can look different outside. Rodgers is forty‑two with a broken hand and still cut it; Tua’s arm just isn’t built for this.
Steelers coached it right—choked off Miami’s run game and made them throw, and that’s game over in those conditions. Rodgers was efficient with one real wideout, the big tight ends did damage, and Darnell Washington looks like he could make tackle money if he ever wanted to switch.
I still see Pittsburgh as one‑and‑done unless they pull the right matchup, and hopefully TJ Watt’s back soon. They’ve steadied the ship, but the AFC gauntlet is real.
Miami’s problem is bigger than a bad night. You can’t build your winter plan around a quarterback who can’t drive it in wind and cold and also doesn’t add anything with his legs. That contract aged like milk—if you can’t trade him, I’d cut bait and move on.
On the Packers, this is where LaFleur and Jeff Hafley can raise their stock. Rally the room, cover for a big defensive loss, and stack wins on a short week against the Bears. Leaders don’t mope; they adjust fast. Don’t count them out from winning the division and grabbing a playoff win.
Why so many older quarterbacks? College ball is clap counts and sideline play calls, the portal and coaching churn stunt growth, and the CBA stripped practice reps. Coaches trust veterans who speak their language and protect games. That’s why a Flacco or a Rivers gets the nod over a toolsy but raw kid.
Mailbag: I think the Chiefs move Chris Jones to a cap‑healthy team tied to a rookie quarterback, not to the Niners. San Francisco should get younger up front and probably keep Mac Jones as inexpensive Purdy insurance rather than chase pricey vets.
Greatest tight end depends on the lane. As receivers, Kelsey and Tony Gonzalez are at the top. As complete tight ends, Gronk was a cheat code and Kittle is the closest thing we’ve seen to that blend of mauling and yards after contact.
Michigan’s mess is a reminder that winning buys cover and losing invites crusades. College rules feel arbitrary, boosters run hot, and when the scoreboard turns, the walls close in.
Harbaugh with Herbert is a rocket booster. Herbert was never overrated; his coaching was. Jim wins everywhere with toughness, run game, and defense, and the Chargers badly needed that adult in the room.
I barely watch the NBA anymore. Life, work, and football eat the calendar, so I track it through pods and box scores more than live games.
Bills‑Patriots showed the gap between a battle‑tested star and a talented young guy. It was the biggest stage of Drake May’s life, Josh Allen was untouchable, and the late‑game offense was on the coaches more than the kid. Vrabel and Josh need to settle him down fast with the Ravens up next.
Hit the Instagram DMs at John Middlekauff for the mailbag, subscribe to the 3 and Out feed, and we’ll be live Thursday night after Rams‑Seahawks. See you then.