About this episode
Former NFL scout John Middlekauff reacts to the news of the day that saw John Harbaugh being fired in Baltimore. John dives into how we knew all season that this was possible, what's next for Baltimore and where should Harbaugh look to next to coach? Next, John talks about Washington moving on from Kliff Kingsbury and why they both decided to part ways, the changes made to the Cowboys defense, and the wild college transfer portal and how it's changing the college football landscape. Finally, John answers your questions in this episode's mailbag segment. 04:22 - John Harbaugh fired in Baltimore 21:01 - Cowboys make a change on defense 29:41 - Carlie Irsay Gordon and the Colts 34:12 - College football transfer portal 41:45 - Dad Diaries 53:11 - Mailbag Follow John on Twitter , Instagram and YouTube for the latest. All lines provided by Hard Rock Bet Use promo code “3ANDOUT20” on https://nicokick.com/zone for 20% off at checkout! Check out Gametime - the fastest growing ticketing app in the US, and the official ticketing app of 3 & Out and GoLow - for tickets to all of your favorite NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA teams. Concert and comedy show tickets, too. Go to Gametime now to create an account, download the app and use code JOHN for $20 off your first purchase. #Volume See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Episode summary
Quick reset at the top: I laid down a show, then on the way to a baby checkup I saw the bombshell that John Harbaugh was out, came back, hit record, and we’re diving into that, a wild coaching day, some college football chaos, the new Dad Diaries, and a packed mailbag with live shows all weekend.
Seeing a pillar like Harbaugh go after nearly two decades is a jaw-dropper; this is a guy who recently had the one seed, a powerhouse roster, and a home title game, and now he’s gone.
Early chatter says ownership wanted changes on offense and the staff resisted, which made an already odd offensive year feel like a philosophy clash; you can argue it was time, but replacing a coach of that caliber is almost always a downgrade.
He instantly becomes the top coach on the market by a mile, the kind of hire teams would fire their guy to land; the Giants fit screams off the page, while the Ravens’ opening is easily the best job with a real quarterback, a stable owner, and elite scouting.
Expect Baltimore to look to their tree for the next guy, someone in the Mike Macdonald and Jesse Minter mold, and the tone of Harbaugh’s polished exit suggests this split was on the table for a bit.
Do not be shocked if owners with coaches already in place start making calls; think Commanders or Bucs types who love big names, because this was one of those league-rattling days.
On Dallas, the Eberflus move read like a front-office reversal of a forced hire; Brian Schottenheimer’s offense showed real juice while the defense cratered, and this felt like Jerry conceding control back to the play caller.
Cliff Kingsbury is out in Washington, and the PR spin cannot hide it; he’s cashing checks from multiple stops, the scheme does not scare top defenses, and Dan Quinn now has to pick a quarterback-friendly system closer to the Shanahan or McVay world to protect Jayden Daniels, or the new NBA-minded ownership will churn again.
Ownership notes: a recent presser offered little clarity on long-term vision while a long-tenured GM stays despite middling results, the roster has age and speed issues, and with the Texans stabilized, the pressure is rising fast.
Transfer portal and NIL: coaches are bluntly pushing out guys who will not play, high school recruits are getting squeezed, and starters are making serious money; quarterbacks now pull approximately one to five million, so mid-round prospects stay because college pays, which is incredible and a little wild for young money management.
Dad Diaries: the little man might need a C-section next week thanks to a big dome and breech position; I’m fired up and laughing at the mountain of modern baby gear compared to our 80s and 90s childhoods where we basically had a crib and a car seat and called it a day.
Mailbag—are teams hiding plays in Week 18? Mostly a myth; by then there is not much to stash, unless a team flat-out punted the game, and if you are Denver you want the Steelers draw.
Will Jon Gruden coach again? Doubt it; great television, but as a coach he was overrated, drafted poorly, and wants too much power.
Could a top quarterback refuse certain teams? NIL cash gives real leverage now, so yes, it could happen, and some destinations remain tough sells no matter the paycheck.
Tyler Shuck looked the part down the stretch: big, mobile, a surprising touch thrower, and trending like a starter even with a thin supporting cast and a bad pick mixed in.
Why do older coaches fade? The daily fire and stamina slip in your 70s; Andy still lives at the office, but most humans eventually lose that edge and perspective shifts.
What about Todd Bowles? He is a legit defensive coach; unless a clear offensive upgrade is available, change for change’s sake is not smart.
Is someone truly the worst in the NFC North? That division is tight and decided by inches, so labeling a cellar team misses how close those games were.
Tight end boom: teams love the size-speed mismatches and run-game value, plus you get formation flexibility that makes defensive coordinators miserable.
Lamar and the Ravens: sometimes it is a make-or-miss moment with the kicker; the online venom is gross, and Baltimore will rally around their MVP and reload.
Pete Carroll back to college? That chapter’s closed; enjoy life, because the NIL era is a different grind.
Draft note: teams sitting in the teens can bundle picks and go hunt a blue-chipper if they want to swing big.
Phoenician trip tips: hit Old Town Scottsdale for the scene, grab Mastro’s or The Mission for dinner, and Houston’s if you want comfort food done right.
Eagles heat check: if the offense sputters against the 49ers, expect staff changes; in clean weather they should live in the high 20s or 30.
Could Andy win without Mahomes? Give an elite offensive coach an offseason and a competent quarterback, and you can function; most defensive head coaches cannot pull that off.
MVP vibe for the year felt too quarterback-only again, and I keep coming back to how dominant Puka Nacua was from start to finish.