About this episode
Former NFL scout John Middlekauff is reacting LIVE immediately following the Week 16 NFL Super Saturday matchup between Jordan Love and the Green Bay Packers vs. Caleb Williams and the Chicago Bears. John kicks off by reacting to a HUGE OT win by Caleb Williams and the Bears to defeat the Packers in Week 16. John applauds Caleb Williams and head coach Ben Johnson for spearing the comeback effort in the game after the Packers had lost QB Jordan Love to a concussion. John then reacts to Jalen Hurts and the Philadelphia Eagles win vs. the Washington Commanders in Week 16. John wraps up by reacting to each of the College Football Playoff 1st round games: Alabama defeats Oklahoma on the road, Miami defeats Texas A&M in a defensive battle, and Oregon and Ole Miss blow out James Madison and Tulane, respectively. 02:48 - Packers-Bears Reaction 35:22 - Eagles-Commanders 39:26 - Alabama-Oklahoma 40:22 - Miami-Texas A&M 40:39 - JMU-Oregon | Tulane-Ole Miss Follow John on Twitter , Instagram and YouTube for the latest. All lines provided by Hard Rock Bet Use promo code “3ANDOUT20” on https://nicokick.com/zone for 20% off at checkout! Check out Gametime - the fastest growing ticketing app in the US, and the official ticketing app of 3 & Out and GoLow - for tickets to all of your favorite NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA teams. Concert and comedy show tickets, too. Go to Gametime now to create an account, download the app and use code JOHN for $20 off your first purchase. #Volume See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Episode summary
What’s going on, everybody—did we just see that? Down sixteen to six with five minutes left, an onside kick, and Caleb Williams turning a cold, windy night into an instant Chicago moment; tonight is about Caleb and the Bears.
How did it feel in the building? It was big-time, college‑rivalry energy in a classic football town, and for most of the night Green Bay controlled pace with a heavy run game while Jeff Hafley’s defense kept Caleb bottled up.
What flipped the script? The onside kick—one of the craziest plays in sports—took a wicked hop, the returner felt heat coming, and Chicago pounced; that’s the rarest kind of momentum swing.
What did Caleb actually show? Late-game poise, big-arm throws that cut through thirty-mile-an-hour gusts, and timely legs; he hit the tying score to Jade Walker and then dropped a gorgeous walk-off to DJ Moore, the kind only a few guys can make in that weather.
Would you go for two there? No—you take the sure point at home against a backup quarterback; Ben Johnson nailed that decision even after an earlier cute goal-line call he’ll want back.
Why the slow field-goal operation? In that wind the kicker has to set his line and tempo, so the patience made sense; once the onside worked, Chicago could methodically work short outs and scrambles before Caleb beat the blitz on fourth down.
What does this mean for the Bears? It’s one of their best wins in a decade-plus, it snaps that psychological ownership vibe, and it sets up a real shot Monday with extra rest; Caleb’s traits fit this city’s cold and wind, and I’d even sprinkle in a few designed keepers because he’s fast and smart about contact.
And the Packers? Brutal—Jordan Love goes out, Malik Willis steps in and plays well, Hafley calls a terrific game, and you still let it slip; results matter, and between earlier late-game stumbles and this, the playoff path gets shakier and the LaFleur extension conversation gets complicated even if he’s a good coach.
Quick on the Eagles: they handled Washington, the offense is streaky but dangerous, the defense is sturdy, and Jake Elliott’s wobble is a real concern in tight January games—they won’t hesitate to act if trust erodes.
College note: Alabama’s win under Kalen DeBoer just confirms he’s a big‑game coach, while the bowl blowouts showed why the little‑guy versus powerhouse setup doesn’t work in football; split these tiers and give the Group of Five its own playoff, because this isn’t March Madness and money is driving the matchups anyway.
Congrats to Caleb Williams and the Bears—walk-off bomb, onside magic, and a frozen crowd losing its mind; what a night.