About this episode
Andrew Wilson has participated in thousands of debates on political, cultural, and religious topics. He is the host of “The Crucible” and proprietor of its associated online school, Debate University.www.youtube.com/@The_Cruciblewww.rumble.com/c/TheCruciblewww.thecrucible.videowww.debateuniversity.com Perplexity: Download the app or ask Perplexity anything at https://pplx.ai/rogan. Don’t miss out on all the action this week at DraftKings! Download the DraftKings app today! Sign-up using https://dkng.co/rogan or through my promo code ROGAN. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER, (800) 327-5050 or visit gamblinghelplinema.org (MA). Call 877-8-HOPENY/text HOPENY (467369) (NY). Please Gamble Responsibly. 888-789-7777/visit https://ccpg.org (CT), or visit https://www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD). 21+ and present in most states. (18+ DC/KY/NH/WY). Void in ONT/OR/NH. Eligibility restrictions apply. On behalf of Boot Hill Casino & Resort (KS). Pass-thru of per wager tax may apply in IL. 1 per new customer. Must register new account to receive reward Token. Must select Token BEFORE placing min. $5 bet to receive $300 in Bonus Bets if your bet wins. Min. -500 odds req. Token and Bonus Bets are single-use and non-withdrawable. Bet must settle by and Token expires 2/22/26. Bonus Bets expire in 7 days (168 hours). Stake removed from payout. Terms: https://sportsbook.draftkings.com/promos. Ends 2/15/26 at 11:59 PM ET. Sponsored by DK. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Episode summary
We kick off riffing on “change my mind” vibes, then slide into Candace getting roasted online and how chasing ever-wilder conspiracies forces constant one‑upmanship.
I’ve watched those channels spike and crash; credibility fades when you go from real‑world ties to time travel and Mandela effects.
That Art Bell energy was to let callers run; I loved the Bigfoot prank caller and even did a Bigfoot hunt for TV where everyone felt like the same guy in different flannels.
Missing 411 hooked me too, but people forget how fast the wild erases remains, which makes mundane explanations more likely.
Bodies vanish out there because scavengers and weather do work, which is why you never find mountain lion skeletons even though they’re everywhere.
Country folks see that cycle daily; a carcass is gone in no time, so you do not need Bigfoot or UFOs to explain disappearances.
People crave a watcher in the woods story, but nature already has a cleanup plan; that’s the pattern they ignore.
Online, that missing‑cases guy hints at a “wild man” but never says; mystery sells better than answers.
There’s always a new cavern‑giants or underground grays story, yet the real unknowns are the deep ocean and a few remote jungles.
Nature still surprises me; I just learned Siberian musk deer have fangs and use them in fights, which looks unreal until you see video.
Variation is wild; gorillas have fangs without eating meat, and entire ecosystems mesh into this tight food web most people never experience.
If more people felt the old reality of wolves at the door, some modern ideas would hit different; safety has made us forget the stakes.
Reintroducing wolves can be smart or dumb depending on where and how; in places like Colorado, they moved known cattle killers near ranches and chaos followed.
Michigan hunters still fume about coyotes introduced to curb deer that then hammered pheasant, and that kind of cascading effect is everywhere.
Coyotes adapted so hard they’re in every state and city, even Central Park, and laws that ignore reality only make urban‑predator clashes worse.
That decline in once‑perfect places hurts to watch; bad policy and bad leaders can wreck paradise fast.
Media smugness collapses when the scaffolding’s gone, which is why some ex‑anchors look lost in podcasting where you have to think in real time.
I never planned this; I went from gunsmith to food‑plant robotics, got sidelined by lockdowns, started debating online, and it grew from there.
Staying unfazed helps; it keeps you sane and humble when strangers know your name.
Family razzing keeps me grounded more than any audience ever could.
Hip injuries after a simple fall are no joke at our age, which is why taking care of yourself matters more each year.
I’m even rethinking smokes; little cigarillos can be a trap because the nicotine hit is serious.
Ron White quit both cigs and booze after a doctor gave him the hard truth; alcohol’s the one dependency that can kill you if you stop cold.
People used beer to step off hard spirits for centuries because abrupt withdrawal can be lethal.
Distillation history is ancient, alchemy never cracked gold, and modern colliders can technically flip atoms but only in microscopic amounts with massive machines.
There are likely more colliders than we know, and if a tool has any boom potential, the military wants a version of it.
We even abandoned a giant Texas collider mid‑build, which shows how huge and political these projects are.
Direct energy weapons are scaling; I still want my plasma rifle like a sci‑fi nerd.
About the Minneapolis shooting: people need to know it was Customs and Border Protection assisting, protests are coordinated not organic, and concealed carriers should never physically engage while armed.
I taught CPL classes; the rule is avoid conflict, carry ID, and stay clear of volatile scenes, or you risk exactly this kind of escalation.
Media even tweaked the suspect’s photo to make him look more heroic, which shows narrative is part of the operation.
These campaigns bank on attrition: keep federal officers in nightly standoffs without local police relief, wait for a bad incident, then use it as fuel.
In the scramble, a SIG P320 may have discharged without a trigger pull, which is plausible given documented drop‑fire issues pre‑2017 and even a police department stepping away from that model.
Even if this case ends up being a clean malfunction or a bad shoot, it is being used to brand CBP and ICE as jackboots and to justify protests that began well before any shooting.
This is classic color‑revolution staging, and many well‑meaning people inside that bubble truly think they’re stopping fascism.
We can argue definitions of fascism all day, but the belief is sincere even if the label is wrong.
On deportations, millions left without force and a significant slice were violent offenders, which matters when you also change districts with raw population and block voter ID.
If voters say they want illegal immigration stopped, blocking that agenda while claiming to defend democracy is a contradiction, and they will try to jam Trump through impeachment if they retake the House.
I call it suicidal empathy; people with kind hearts get used by cynics chasing permanent control, and the UK shows how far speech policing can go when a state gets comfy.
Influencers now wield real political capital, and some will justify any means if they truly believe they’re fighting literal Nazis.
The weirdest part is watching soft‑spoken guys call for street violence with gamer slang, which would be funny if it was not so reckless.
He stares into the camera and talks like it’s Dungeons and Dragons, and that’s the vibe—online cosplay where people feel heroic from the couch while they cheer on real harm and call it justice.
I’ve seen far‑left online spaces lure unstable people and turn them into expendable shock troops who don’t fear dying, then frame it as martyrdom.
Mix preexisting issues with psychiatric meds that can fuel violent thoughts and you get a powder keg.
Women take more SSRIs, and you see lots of them on the megaphones; the broader picture shows mental health skewing hard by ideology too.
Surveys show conservatives report far better mental health, and I think habits like accountability and discipline explain a lot of that gap.
To me, psychology feels like ritual with data collection, not real science, and men often get more from honest friends than a therapist’s tricks.
Problem is many guys don’t have solid friends, but the data still shows conservatives thriving more, which fits with purpose and routine.
These days being conservative starts with a religious framework, which grounds ethics in something fixed instead of utilitarian vibes.
Church folks are unfailingly kind, even in the parking lot; if there were a pill or therapy that made people that generous, everyone would take it.
Kindness isn’t the same as niceness, but a shared moral duty shifts attention off me, me, me—and even a skeptic could see the civic upside.
Jordan Peterson’s point lands for me—live as if God is real and life gets better—and the most strident atheists I know seem deeply unhappy.
Pure secularism’s track record is ugly, and the Christian model stands out for forgiveness, like the monk who kept cutting his vice in half.
Without forgiveness, the left devours its own over tiny missteps because everyone fears being next.
Maybe the purity spiral is a feature, not a bug—it burns off dissent until one message rules, which can be powerful.
Communism needs enforcers with guns and kills incentives; excellence requires rewards, and competition raises the bar for everyone.
Central planners can’t price a guitar, much less a life; most people’s outcomes trace back to their own choices more than fate.
Trust‑fund kids often come apart because they never formed properly, and yes, the Cold War fight is back; I still want safety nets, but modern mega‑charities and homeless spending are a racket.
If you pay the most and make it easiest, more homeless arrive, and entitlements become budget black holes and political weapons—Social Security should be a lockbox, not a slush fund.
Government returns are awful compared to investing yourself, and this mushy empathy extends to defending the indefensible, like ritual abuse some anthropologists downplay with relativism.
Sometimes force is the moral choice; the same goes for cultures that tore hearts out on pyramids, which shatters the myth of the noble savage.
The Aztec numbers are staggering, the Mayans weren’t gentle either, and on the plains the Comanche ruled by brutal mastery; everyone colonized someone.
The two‑spirit narrative is overblown, domesticated animals were the civilizational cheat code, and disease immunity tracked with that.
Even Europeans likely got syphilis out of the exchange, and migration is humanity’s story, but today the left uses colonizer talk to strip birthright legitimacy from Americans.
So what’s the left’s endgame—just destroy the right and call it antifascism?
They think power fixes everything, but look at Obama‑era deportations and old Hillary clips—Democrats once sounded like hardliners, which shows how much is theater.
Unions used to demand strict enforcement, even Bernie warned about cheap‑labor schemes; the left just swaps issues to grab power.
It’s power games all the way down—import voters, rig rules, then insist it’s for compassion.
Given that, Christian nationalism looks like a rational push to keep hostile ideologies out of power.
I get the impulse, but people fear a theocracy, and human nature tends to twist power no matter the banner.
The serious versions don’t call for a theocracy; they want Christians unashamed to govern by Christian ethics rather than left rules of engagement.
Politicians keep problems alive to fundraise, so only real Christian ethics—not jet‑set televangelism—would help, and it still beats amoral climbers.
Debates wear me down because I argue from a Christian moral base while many opponents don’t even believe their own lines, so sometimes you have to break bad ideas so others won’t follow them.
Wild that you were a regular working guy who stumbled into this and then the pandemic pushed you to jump in.
A layoff gave me time, I educated myself across sources, and two years in I quit a stable job on faith I could make this work.
You’ve got a rare knack for exposing bad logic, and that’s genuinely useful.
I answer DMs every morning and take the responsibility seriously because I’m representing a worldview for people looking for bearings.
Seeing someone finally push back helps people who were drifting on slick but empty arguments.
Even a draw can pause a bad conversion, and many tell me a debate nudged them toward Christianity; funny enough, higher‑status opponents tend to be softer because media rewards connections, not merit.
There are plenty of glossy names who never should’ve been on air.
Exactly—some were tokens selling prefab talking points, not insight.
This was great—let’s run it back; tell people where to find you.
Watch The Crucible on YouTube, grab my wife’s book on cult feminism, and check out Debate University if you want real reps learning how to argue.
Appreciate you coming in; keep doing what you’re doing.