About this episode
Nik Nocturnal is a musician, YouTuber, and content creator. What is happening in modern metal music? The days of thrash and hair metal dominating culture are long gone, and something entirely new has taken their place. So what defines modern metal, why does it sound so different, and how has the internet changed the music industry forever? Expect to learn how big of an impact TikTok plays in shaping the way modern metal songs are written, which songs are the most influential songs in modern metal, what Nik thinks of AI-generated music, the most overused trends in metal right now, the tension between making art and making “content” in music, the worst thing about being a YouTube musician and much more… Sponsors: See discounts for all the products I use and recommend: https://chriswillx.com/deals Get 160+ lab tests for just $365 and save an extra $25 at https://functionhealth.com/modernwisdom Get 10% discount on all Gymshark products at https://gym.sh/modernwisdom (use code MODERNWISDOM10) Get 15% off your first order of my favourite Non-Alcoholic Brew at https://athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom Get 35% off your first subscription on the best supplements from Momentous at https://livemomentous.com/modernwisdom Get ChatGPT to explore ideas, solve problems, and learn faster at https://chatgpt.com Timestamps: (0:00) How is TikTok Reshaping Metal Music? (8:24) Is Metal Music Better Than Ever? (17:36) Are We Living in a Golden Age of Metal? (25:39) How Pop Culture Is Reviving Metal (28:28) The Best Metal Songs for Nostalgia (34:55) Is Originality Dead in Music? (41:29) Is There Beef in the Metal Genre? (47:02) Who is Slipknot’s New Drummer? (50:22) How Long Have Kilswitch Engage Been Around? (51:05) Why is Metal Becoming Self-Aware? (54:04) How Hit Songs Are Really Made (58:52) Are Bands Being Engineered for Virality? (01:06:49) The Building Blocks of Nik’s Fast Songwriting (01:16:52) The Hidden Costs of Taking a Break (01:27:06) Why Creators Burn Out So Fast (01:35:51) The Power of the “F*ck You” Pivot (01:40:34) Are Streaming Platforms Exploiting Artists? (01:53:44) How Song DNA is Improving Credit (01:56:16) What’s Next For the Alt Music Scene? (02:08:59) Metal Bands You Shouldn’t Miss (02:16:23) Where to Find Nik Extra Stuff: Get my free reading list of 100 books to read before you die: https://chriswillx.com/books Try my productivity energy drink Neutonic: https://neutonic.com/modernwisdom Episodes You Might Enjoy: #577 - David Goggins - This Is How To Master Your Life: lnkfi.re/SN-Goggins #712 - Dr Jordan Peterson - How To Destroy Your Negative Beliefs: lnkfi.re/SN-Peterson #700 - Dr Andrew Huberman - The Secret Tools To Hack Your Brain: lnkfi.re/SN-Huberman - Get In Touch: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chriswillx Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/chriswillx YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/modernwisdompodcast Email: https://chriswillx.com/contact - Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode summary
How much has TikTok shaped modern metal?
A lot. Young listeners live there, and modern metal is full of instant payoffs, so the best fifteen seconds—breakdowns, wild vocals, drum or guitar flashes—hook people fast like a jump scare, which pulls the genre into wider view.
Look at Can You Feel My Heart. Great song, but the internet turned it into the biggest Bring Me track by miles. Are bands now writing with short clips in mind and seeding memes on purpose?
Many are aware. Writing has shifted to laptops, producers, and even AI, so people sometimes build the climax first and reverse‑engineer the rest. One outrageous moment can blow up, though the best cases—like Knocked Loose—work because the songs are paced to hit naturally, not because they chased clips.
Social should be a window, not the product. If you craft for it, you also have to hide that you did, which kills the magic.
Right, and you often end up with hype and a weak song. It spikes, then nobody replays it because it was built as a meme, not a keeper.
I’m feeling a revival. I still remember bass drops in a friend’s car shaking my teeth, subwoofer in the boot, full chaos when it hit.
That era’s 808 insanity was legendary. Genres were looser—post‑hardcore mixed with metal—and those unfiltered moments are back, which is why Bring Me re‑visiting early material lands so well. Those songs are full of clip‑ready hits.
Plenty of old pop and hip‑hop get TikTok revivals, less so metal. Architects’ Doomsday felt huge, and Mick Gordon’s Doom sound changed modern heaviness. Jordan Fish widened Bring Me’s world with bigger, more electronic production. Architects are the slow burn champs.
Staying that consistent is rare. Newer breakouts—Sleep Token, Bad Omens, Loathe—blend heavy with dreamy or R&B‑leaning hooks, and the mix feels natural now instead of stitched together.
Earlier A Day To Remember could feel split in two. Architects flipped the script with heavy verses and melodic choruses and made it flow.
The rise‑core wave threw synths at breakdowns for fun, but it was choppy. Over time, producers learned to blend, and sound design leveled up fast.
Mastering jumped. You bring in the Doom guy, then everyone studies how he made it feel massive.
Now guitars sit inside a broader design. Some scenes stay riff‑first, but a lot of modern metal expects layers, synths, and polish on top of tight writing.
Cross‑genre stuff keeps popping. MGK teaming up with heavy acts is a thing now.
I think it’s fun even if the track misses. Metal fans can punish crossovers, but sometimes the culture shock hits right, and younger listeners grew up on mixed playlists anyway.
I used to run a huge Saturday club night. We hosted raging pits for bands, then flipped to a packed dance floor. You’d get Suicide Silence upstairs, then a line of club kids outside. Worlds colliding. Now parents and kids trade bands—Sleep Token one way, Every Time I Die the other.
That’s why modern acts with big choruses and heavy drops cut across generations. My mom once panicked when I got into metal, but the satanic‑panic days have faded and the lineage from 2000s to now is easier to hear.
For me it’s still Taking Back Sunday and The Used, but I’m game for new shots at it. Production is just very different now.
Alexisonfire and Bullet are my comfort food. City and Colour blew up while he was also in a heavy band, which felt wild at the time.
Those records were pure feeling. Total retention killer to play them mid‑show, and I don’t care.
That era ruled because we had discovery without constant capture. Games and TV funneled us new music—Guitar Hero, Tony Hawk, even sports titles.
Exactly. Limp Bizkit on Mission Impossible. Scene‑kid wars over what was real metal, yet everyone secretly loved the catchy stuff.
Messy, but it birthed classics. I still spin Killswitch, All That Remains, Atreyu, and a stack of trilogies that feel like start‑to‑finish journeys.
We score tour vlogs with that era too. It’s harder to on‑ramp listeners who expect today’s sheen, which is why re‑recording early tracks can bridge the gap. Some new bands absolutely nail that mid‑2000s brutality—the trash‑can snare and speaker‑killing 808s—while sounding current.
Bring Me’s path is insane—deathcore to pop to nu‑metal to deathcore again—and it works because they’re fearless. Jordan Fish quietly shifted the whole field with bold synths, big progressions, and pop‑grade size. Bad Omens and Sleep Token own that moody night‑drive energy.
Originality often means being the first to popularize. Hulk Hogan didn’t invent the moves, he owned them. Same in metal: it’s who makes it land.
There are no new chords. Uniqueness comes from feel—tempo, key, groove, sound design—and how you arrange familiar parts.
So should vocals and lyrics be the key differentiator now?
Themes repeat, clichés abound, and words get overused, but delivery matters. Cadence, tone, and context can make old ideas feel fresh, which is why copy accusations get murky fast.
Ed Sheeran showed that most hits ride the same few chords. Metal’s scene is small, so public beef is rare. You still need partners, so don’t torch bridges.
Everyone knows everyone. If you’re a jerk, word travels. Or you lean in and make that your brand.
Ronnie Radke is basically the heel. You can hold the belt and still make pissing people off your job.
MySpace and Warped bred provocateurs. Rockstar chaos was part of the draw.
Industry lines blur anyway. Pop pros often grew up in heavy music.
Right, and today’s heavy is producer‑first. Expect layered synths, quad guitars, and drums that are “raw” but reinforced, because punch rules live and online.
What’s with Slipknot’s new drummer?
Lineups change, but the new guy is a powerhouse. Extreme drumming’s athletic now, and nu‑metal’s reach still pulls kids into songs like Chop Suey decades later.
These bands have been at it for ages. Killswitch keeps landing timeless tracks. Metal also feels more self‑aware and ironic lately. Why?
Nostalgia fuels it. We’re re‑embracing MySpace‑era weirdness and joke titles, but the songs still have to stick or the TikTok bump disappears.
Why did The Summoning break Sleep Token to the moon while other bangers stayed big but not massive?
They built a killer catalog and then dropped the perfect moment. Internet noticed. You can engineer timing and distribution a bit, but you can’t fake the banger.
Feels like some people know the playbook.
I’ve watched how campaigns move, even if I’m not the one pulling levers.
I see coordinated rumors and synchronized posts across accounts.
Reddit seeding, clip farms, and burner networks are tools now. It’s standard to simulate momentum.
Wired dug into Geese and a firm that runs swarms of pages, drops songs into background clips, forges UGC, and spins fake discourse to trick algorithms. That risks becoming the entry fee instead of a cheeky boost.
Content has been gamified for years. View‑inflation stories are everywhere. Labels using networks doesn’t shock me.
I love the new project President, but it launched huge on the masked‑anonymity wave. People cry plant fast, even when the songs slap.
Veterans roll an alt with endgame knowledge. Fast progress feels unfair from the outside, but it can just be smart execution meeting great music.
Guerrilla flyers or algorithm hacks—both are marketing. People mostly resent momentum they don’t think was earned.
Metal fans invest with their wallets and hearts, which is amazing. That same passion turns into the loudest backlash when a band shifts gears, because it feels personal.
I built a series called How to Metal where I’d sketch a band’s vibe in 30 seconds, then jam an eight-second riff, and people asked for full versions, so I live-wrote tracks in a couple hours and dropped a song a week until I burned out.
Time off reset me; I got healthy, wrote weird hybrids—electronic, funk, and heavy influences—and realized I don’t want to slide back into reaction videos or scene news just because it performs.
Did you feel pushed to weigh in on every headline, even the dark stuff, just because the audience expected it?
Totally, and I hated it; the sad stories didn’t need my take, the negative topics traveled farther, and I didn’t want to feed that loop or stain my days with it.
Drama lords exist in every niche; it’s commentary on commentary on commentary, like financial derivatives piled high.
Leaving made me okay with closing the book if I had to; I love this world, but I needed to be at peace without it and decide how I can add value without losing myself.
Walk me through the hiatus—slowing down, sharing a career with your wife, and facing that identity shift.
She makes music too, but my career was built as a single-player grind, and I’d run to film a video while she wrote in the next room when all I wanted was to write with her.
We made no-pressure tracks at home—funk, Brazilian bounce, dance—just for fun, and it reminded me I started as a kid chasing riffs, not metrics; I need balance so my self-worth isn’t welded to uploads.
Momentum can trick you into thinking you chose a path when you never paused to ask if you still want it.
I’m grateful for the audience and history, but the tough-it-out voice wasn’t healthy; stepping back let me like music again for its own sake.
My theory on creator burnout is that our wins arrive as quiet numbers on a screen, not roars from a crowd; the feedback is slower and softer, and isolation eats at meaning.
Exactly; you’re home, up late, alone, missing life like touring does but without the shared highs and memories.
Comfort isn’t purpose; doing hard things with people is, which is why band bus nights can feel better than solo hotel rooms, even if the room is nicer.
It’s wild that kids dream of YouTube now; some OGs like PewDiePie quietly chose family and peace, and I respect that pivot.
Call it the “fuck you family” phase: when love at home outranks industry clout, like Pewds choosing a gentler lane.
Filthy Frank becoming Joji was the ultimate clean exit—total reinvention—and once you’re out, it’s hard to cancel what you’re not making.
Platforms aren’t loyal, so I had to diversify; a policy tweak can nuke your AdSense, which is why I value Twitch, Patreon, products, and anything off-platform.
What’s your read on streaming payouts and label friction right now?
Artists feel underpaid, but many also signed deals that recoup forever; awareness is better now, yet contracts can still trade freedom for advances that take ages to clear.
Watch Artifact—the 30 Seconds to Mars doc—it shows how savage 360s get; it’s your life on the first page.
Some deals are more flexible today, but owing multiple albums can be a decade-long marriage to a label while you’re also married to your bandmates; some need that structure, others get trapped.
The music business still feels archaic, from distribution hoops to metadata sprawl, even as podcasts got push-button simple.
Distro tools help, but releases still mean checklists and credits; Spotify’s Song DNA is a step forward, and publishing databases often reveal the “anonymous” anyway.
Where’s alternative music heading over the next few years—what excites you and what worries you?
I’m stoked on genre-mixing and song-first thinking, but wary of Octane-style templates where labels clone radio-friendly heavy and sand the edges.
At the same time, the underground is getting weirder in a good way—thall grooves with classical or dubstep drops, R&B over riffs—heavy hunting for new heaviness.
There’s prestige in scarce mainstream slots like games and TV, while YouTube remains wide open; I can see the scene splitting further in both directions.
I hope metal lifts the small innovators, and we chill on gatekeeping; bands like Sleep Token blend pop and heavy, and fans can’t demand they stay one thing forever.
The hate is goofy; the UK’s punching above its weight in heavy music, so I’ll take the wins.
Shout out to the UK and Canada; Toronto crowds love prog and post-hardcore—Protest the Hero, Alexisonfire, Intervals—and yes, Billy Talent still rips.
Hit me with recommendations; I’ve got one too.
Spin Billy Talent’s Fallen Leaves for a hook clinic, and check Morar for thall with classical and dubstep twists; try Easily Erased for melodic cleans over scream-led peaks.
My pick is Holy Water—shoegaze and modern heavy with real bite; I’m smug I could slide you something new.
I’m glad you took a break and even gladder you’re back; where should people find you?
@nicknocturnal everywhere, and I’m launching daily live song-writing sessions with reactive lights, building tracks start to finish on stream and releasing the ones people demand.
Sometimes my wife will jump in to produce or we’ll tag-team a beat, and if a demo takes off, we’ll shoot a DIY video and send it out.
Love it—let’s do this again soon; thanks for rolling through. Bye everybody.